I really don't know where 1up is trying to go with this anti Wii bias. They are free to have that bias, but as far as a commercial website, I would think that it would be in their best interest to be as balanced as possible.
I haven't played it, but from reading the other reviews I see it like this: at worst, the Wii version (I think) is still on par or better than the PS2 version because it adds in better online, pretty solid motion controls, lots more mini-games, and best of all the "Telestrator".
off-off-topic: Planet Earth changed my life. It had me saying two things the whole time I was watching it, "I wish I lived on that planet, and I wish I had a 1080p television for it.
Watch this if you don't own it.
I would cite regulation, but I know you will simply ignore it.
