Hmm browser seemed to go weird when I posted. Will try again.
Gametrailers and Ign are my 2 most trusted sites and they say it's awesome which is enough for me (It's MP though so I never doubted it would be fantastic).
The IGN review did make it sound like it would be a little bit higher (9.6 or 9.7) but with a 9.5 you can't really complain.
I expect gamespot to give it an unusually low score compared to others. Somewhere around 88% wouldn't surprise me.
I understand what they mean about controls though. Even with games like RE4 I notice how much the wii controls improve it. The thought of playing RE5 with dual analog is just annoying. Feels like a massive step backwards.