NeoRatt on 24 August 2007
BioShock is a 8? I completely disagree... 9 is likely, 10 I understand why people don't like throwing 10's out there... But, an 8 is not reviewing it for what it is as a game.
As for Space Giraffe. It stinks... 2 is an exceptionally great rating for it... 4 would have to be a drug addict... 8 indicates that they had someone demo it to them and reviewed based on that.
They gave Moto GP'07 a 7... But they gave Moto GP'06 an 8 and from what I've seen of the demo of GP'07 it is way better then GP'06...
They also gave King Kong an 8 on the 360... That game was not in the same ballpark as Gears or BioShock...
It seems there is inconsistency with their rating system. Not a fanboy comment... Just an observation on their rating system.
