Wiped said:
^ Yes cdude1034. You know what you're talking about, I agree with everything you posted, you're totally right.
Except, I don't agree with you're rankings. R/S/E was better than R/B/Y. Placing the originals over R/S is just nostalgia clouding your vision, imo. Yes, R/S may not have been the best, but when they released, they overhauled the graphics, added some of the best pokemon of the series (quite in keeping with the original 151 style, imo, but with more of an edge), and expanded the competitive battling massively - the addition of EVs, IVs, and a huge expansion of the movepools of all pokemon. D/P perfected what R/S began - and I think it's unfair to rank it so far down.
If you want to pick on one game though, it should be Pokemon Battle Revolution. It's great so see your pokemon in 3D, but that is undeniably a weak game. It just wasnt as good as it should have been. I wanted Pokemon Stadium 2008, I got Pokemon Colloseum with the RPG mode stripped out.
|
While I agree Ru/S was a decent game, I just can't put it ahead of R/B/G/Y. In my experience, I just didn't enjoy it as much as the originals. I did like the improved graphics, abilities, and the berries, but other than that, it really didn't do anything for me.
I completely forgot about Battle Revolution! i absolutely loooooved that game. It's not comparable to the gameboy games though, and I wouldn't know how to rate them against the gameboy games anyway.
Admittedly I've never played Gale of Darkness. Is it any good?
