IMO, and having the expertise of playing FPS for over a decade now, none of the FPS are top notch. Again, IMO, out the bunch, Far Cry 2 is the best....but not by much, R2,L4D,and COD: WAW are all very good games.
With that said, however, I think for $60.00. Resistance 2 offers more content than any of the others.
Check us out at the Vindication Gamer Network on Youtube.