As a Wii/PS3 owner, I'd buy Madden for the Wii with one easy change. If it had a traditional control option that would allow me to either use the classic controller or the gamecube controller.
Madden Wii will never have the attach rate of the 360 or PS3 because multi-console owners will most likely prefer the HD graphics. I could care less. But I tried Madden Wii and the controls are not as tight as traditional controls. They can be fun, but when it gets to all-madden competitive games you don't want controls that work 90-95% of the time. I would probably mess around with the motion controls, but a traditional control option would have me sold.
In fact, that's what I hate about most games. Yes, I love what motion control can accomplish when done right, but games like Mario Kart give the best of both worlds.
