indodude on 21 November 2008
| Dodece said: I am uncertain as to the apparent methodology. Are you picking ten exclusives at random? For instance why use Too Human when Naruto the Broken Bond received an average score of 83 on Metacritic. Why use Infinite Undiscover when Scene it had an average score of 76 on Metacritic. I took the liberty of replacing the lowest valued exclusives on your list with those two exclusives that have had a better reception. The result is that Microsoft actually beats Sony with an average score of 82.5%. At first I thought this was intentional, but I already see one error in the PS3 listing as well. Naruto Ultimate Ninja Storm had a rating of 76 on Metacritic. Unless your discounting it, because it will not release in all regions in the same year. I highly recommend you provide a thorough explanation as to how you reached your numbers, and if I am correct you probably need to do better compiling of data. I was able to find a reasonably solid listing for 360 exclusives on Wikipedia. There should also be listings for the PS3 and for the Wii as well. I think you might want to document all exclusives in the future when you compile such lists so it is easier for users to cross reference your list with their list. To see up front if you are missing a particular title in your analysis. |
Naruto The Broken Bond only has 4 reviews on Metacritic just for the record.
