MP3 vs Bioshock: reviews

[Androo]

sinha said:

superchunk said:
Well, I havn't played either, but this is what i would expect from what I have read about both.

Graphics = Bio
User Interface = MP3
Total Gametime = MP3
Multiplayer = Bio
Sound = Bio
Overall Score = Bio (MP3 will get knocked down due to wii biased, though it will be one of Wii's highest, if not highest rated games thus far)

Love BioShock winning "multiplayer"!

Two you forgot:

Story = Bio

Atmosphere = Bio

 

So if BioShock has a higher overall score than Metroid it will only be because the hundred or so game review sites out there have some sort of collective anti-Wii bias?  The current score for BioShock is 98.1, obviously it will fall somewhat... but you're really saying what will keep Metroid from beating that score is not that it's a ridiculously high score that would be tough for almost any game to beat, but instead some sort of industry-wide anti-Wii bias?  And of course you will provide no factual evidence to support your conspiracy theory, correct?  So, that's really the rationalization you're choosing to go with here?  Really?

 

Well I agree with superchunk. I'm sure Bioshock is pretty much awsome but still don't tell me that you haven't seen a anti-wii vibe in the reviews? EVERY reviewer has to compare Wii games to 360/PS3 games even though that is completely unecessary. You dont see them comparing the controls in 360/ps3 games to Wii controls do you? So even if Metroid is the best thing to happen to Wii [at least until Galaxy arrives] it won't get the high score it deserves.

And as I said before there WILL be at lest 70% [if not more] of reviewers who complain about the lack of onine multiplayer where up till now we don't see that same complaint for Bioshock. And I completely agree with Bioshock reviews. A game doesn't need to have online multi to be good especially when you have Metroid's high calibur single player game as well as Bioshock's.