Top 5 so far this gen
1.) Tales of Vesperia
2.) Twilight Princess
3.) Super Mario Galaxy
4.) Mario Kart Wii
5.) Dokapon Kingdom (with a group)
- Possibly Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World - just haven't played it yet
- Also NHL 09 for top sports game.
Too many to list in a top 5 for all time. I'd need like a top 20 list just so I didn't feel bad for leaving anything off.