Famitsu has had a decent track record when it comes to calling good X360 games (imo):
TES: Oblivion: 38/40
The Last Remnant: 38/40
Blue Dragon: 37/40
Tales of Vesperia: 35/40
Eternal Sonata: 35/40
Lost Odyssey: 33/40
Infinite Undiscovery: 32/40
Enchanted Arms: 29/40
Except for the Lost Odyssey review, the list seems pretty solid. They gave Oblivion a very high score, despite the fact it's a virtual unknown in Japan. Some may argue Blue Dragon's score, but there's a contingent of us that believe the score is certainly justified.
Back from the dead, I'm afraid.