Does the DS count? It was released in 2004...TWEWY is the closest I believe like people have said.
Star Ocean:TLH has a chance in February, SO:TtEoT got an 81.
WKC has a better chance, but that won't get a Western release before SO:TLH.
I agree about the 85 comment for JRPG's. Valkyria Chronicles has an 87 from Metacritic and Gamerankings which to me is much more impressive then a Shooter with 90.