I have two SIXAXIS controllers and two Dualshock 3 controllers. Once I got the Dualshock 3, I never went back. I didn't realize how much I missed rumble until I had it back. Plus, I just like the feel better; the plastic feels better, it feels sturdier, and I don't feel like I'm using a feather. The only thing I miss is that if you hold a SIXAXIS up to a light, you can see through the handles. That was pretty cool.