De85 on 08 November 2008
First off I don't think Bioshock should be on that list because the game released in 2007. I know the PS3 version just came out, but the story isn't any newer, and that's what this thread is about.
Personally I have to go with Braid as well, but I realize that since the story is pretty open to interpretation not everyone will like it. All I know is that Braid got me thinking like no other game (and very few books) ever has. The last level before the epilogue just blew me away.
edit: fixed date
