To add to the litany of complaints about this list...
* I am a HUGE Diablo fan, but IT IS NOT AN RPG.
* Where is Witcher?
* Although Zelda is more RPG than Diablo (barely) and is certainly the best action RPG IMHO, it does not belong here.
* For the record, ALttP > OoT
* Final Fantasy VII? Really? So the downward turning point of the entire line is number 1, and the gaudy extention of its failed path (FFXII) are the only 2 FF's on the list?
NOT EVERY GAME THAT HAS MYTHICAL OR MYSTICAL ELEMENTS IS AN RPG! There actually has to be ROLE PLAYING. Why is this list even here, and does anybody really know what an RPG actually is anymore?
To that end, WoW trumps any other game here (though I don't even play it) just because of the sheer amount of ROLE PLAYING you can actually do.
I am sure that most if not all of my points are redundant, so my apologies.
