Hawkeye on 06 November 2008
Metal Gear Solid 4...
Grand Theft Auto 4...
Little Big Planet...
Valkeryia Chronicles...
Resistance 2...
Wii has... Brawl
360 has
Gears of War 2...
Fable 2...
Grand Theft Auto I suppose, except that the PS3 version was rated slightly higher.
Personally, I think LBP deserves to win. Its the most unique and moves the industry forward the most of any of the games I listed.
