Sky Render on 05 November 2008
Now there is a genuinely interesting question, and a comparison with some merit.
Both contained old favorites in re-released form, both had the promise of something new, and both were met with much enthusiasm and criticism. Overall, however, Orange Box wins out ever so slightly because it had Portal in it, probably one of the most innovative games made in the last 20 years. All-Stars had only re-releases to show for itself.
Sky Render - Sanity is for the weak.
