MontanaHatchet on 03 November 2008
I'd like for someone to explain how it is a failure in the bounds of any realistic expectations. It has sold a massive amount so far, and will sell millions more through the holiday season and the years beyond. I wouldn't be surprised if the game was still charting, even in small numbers, at the end of the generation (assuming Rockstar never makes a sequel, which I hope they do).
You can argue about quality and reception all you want, but sales wise, it was a great success and still is.
