By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Gaming - Madden 08 reviews - View Post

Diomedes1976 said:

Two ,make direct comparisions between versions .To keep things fair we should compare 360 and PS3 versions ,Wii and PS2 versions and DS and PSP versions .If they insist to compare the Wii version to the 360/PS3 version it should be slaughtered in the graphics/sound departments .


Personally, I would have no problem directly comparing wii with the ps3 and 360. Many reviews did it with Harry Potter, and gave wii the best overall score, even though they gave others a higher score for the graphics.  Where do you get that the PS3 has better sound???  Perhaps in theory it could have if that's all it did was audio, but you need to look at the total experience.  From what I can tell of the specs, the wii has hardware to handle it without bogging down the main CPU, and the PS3 needs to tie up it's cell processors to handle the audio.  Maybe that's part of the problem with the PS3, there just isn't enough processing left for video after it plays sound at the same time?

Seriously, I don't understand these baseless comparisons of PS3 sound is > wii sound.  Maybe it's so, but please site a reference or you just sound like a disgruntled fanboy.