I think I'll go with Kingdom Hearts II, the magic of the original was all gone in this one.
LittleBigPlanet is on my list too, I was very dispointed by the platforming aspect of the game.
I feel like I'll have to defend FFVII. I know it's cool to hate it but I just love that game, the story and mostly the materia system which allows you to customize your character in such fun ways. Also, there's so much to do at the end of the game once you're done with the story (Gold Saucer games, killing the Weapons, Chocobo breeding/racing)
Signature goes here!








