Well ,having read everything you posted ....
We have two options ...
One ,compare the graphics ,sound etc only between the games appeared for the same plattform .So ,Madden on the 360 would only be comparable to Maden 05 and Madden 06 and NcAA games on the 360 .The same for the PS3 ,DS ,Wii ,PSP etc .Then the PS3 version cant be critized that way because at least it is best than last year edition wich scored higher .Then the Wii version has a fair score ,the same with all the others .Everything all right then ,but the PS3 version being critized for running at less FPS is just wrong .The game should be judged after the PS3 football games ,its irrelevant if there is another game in another plattform wich runs better .
Two ,make direct comparisions between versions .To keep things fair we should compare 360 and PS3 versions ,Wii and PS2 versions and DS and PSP versions .If they insist to compare the Wii version to the 360/PS3 version it should be slaughtered in the graphics/sound departments .
I see a bad trend here ,there are a lot of multipattform games on the Wii and PS3 and specially in the DS and PSP that the PSP version is critized for some graphical reason and then the DS version with way worse graphics receives a higher graphical rating as it just "doesnt have to compare " .This is getting ridiculous .
Existing User Log In
New User Registration
Register for a free account to gain full access to the VGChartz Network and join our thriving community.
