@Selnor pt. 2. Man your earlier post was so uninformed or biased that I have to take the time to point out the errors in the entire thing.
"Well if your a gamer buy a 360. It's simple."
Yeah, two years ago...
"The 360 has more variety of games in every category that score higher apart from stealth. Also 80% of multiplat games perform better on the 360."
Wrong.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________
According to IGN, the most respected gaming site on the internet;
The Two consoles tie in the following genres:
The PS2 has two action games that have received scores of 10: Metal Gear Solid 4 and Grand Theft Auto IV. The 360 only has one -- Grand Theft Auto IV.
Both the PS3 and 360 tie for the highest rated action adventure game of this gen Dead Space with an 8.7 (8.8 according to the Australian review); They also tie in the action compilation genre (LEGO Star Wars: The Complete Saga -- 8.0 on both).
The 360 has two Music games that have scores of 9.4 Rock Band and Guitar Hero II while the PS3 only has one that has this score -- Rock Band.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________
The 360 has the top game in the following genres:
The 360 has the top action rpg game (Fable II a 9.5 according to IGN UK, a 9.2 according to IGN AU, and an 8.8 according to IGN US (which is actually lower than the IGN US score for Valkyria Chronicles 9.1 but Valkyria Chronicles isn't an action rpg, so I'm placing it in the strategy role-playing genre).
The 360 has the two highest rated fighting game with Virtua Fighter 5 Online and Dead or Alive 4 which both score 9.0s. The PS3's highest rated fighting game is Virtua Fighter 5 which scores an 8.8.
The 360 has the highest rated Fighting Action game in Small Arms which scores an 8.2
The 360 has the highest rated puzzle action game between the two consoles with astropop which receives a score of 8.0.
The 360 has the highest rated Western RPG with Fallout 3 which receives a score of 9.6 on the 360 while it receives a slightly lower score on the PS3 with a 9.4.
The 360 has the highest rated Racing Simulation game with Forza Motorsport 2 which received a 9.2 from IGN Australia but only an 8.9 from IGN US. Forza Motorsport 2's score from IGN US is only .4 points higher than IGN US gave the demo version of Sony's Gran Turismo 5, so when Gran Tursimo 5 is completed, one would expect that it would surely score much higher than Forza Motorsport 2 as the demo comes within .4 points of doing so, so one can anticipate that this genre will soon shift into Sony's column.
The 360 has the highest rated shooter of this gen in Bioshock which received a score of 9.7 there is also a version of Bioshock on the PS3 which received a score of score of 9.4 from IGN. The PS3 version of the game is newer than the 360 version and includes a lot of bonus content not available in the 360 version. Bioshock is not the PS3's highest rated shooter that is Resistance 2. Resistance 2 received a score of 9.5 from IGN making it just as good according to the reviewes as some other possibly more famous 360 shooters like Gears of War (which was actually given a lower score by IGN US) and Halo 3.
The 360 has the highest rated Sports game between the two consoles with Skate which was given a 9.3 by IGN AU.
The 360 has the highest rated Virtual Pet genre game with Viva Pinata. IGN AU gave Viva Pinata a 9.0; however, Viva Pinata only received an 8.5 from IGN US. Viva Pinata 2: Trouble in Paradise received an 8.6 from IGN AU and an 8.5 from IGN US. The PS3 doesn't have a Virtual Pet game. Earlier someone said the two Viva Pinata games = Little Big Planet, but that is just not the case. Two 8.5s don't equal one 9.5 to 9.7. If anything they are just more of the same while LBP has original elements.
The 360 has the highest rated Wrestling game. WWE Smackdown vs. Raw 2007 received a score of 8.0 and was not available on the PS3.
____________________________________________________________________________________________________
The PS3 has the top game in the following genres:
The PS3 has by far the top adventure game of the two systems with Folklore coming in at a 9.0 while the 360's highest rated adventure game is LEGO Indiana Jones which is only an 8.4).
The PS3 has the highest rated card battle game between the two consoles with the Eye of Judgement scoring an 8.2 according to IGN AU and an 8.0 according to IGN US; the 360 doesn't have a game in the Card Battle genre.
The PS3 has the highest rated Flight Action game with Warhawk which scores an 8.8.
Of the two HD consoles, the PS3 has the highest rated Party game with Snakeball which scores an 8.0.
The PS3 has the highest rated platform games of the two hd consoles with Little Big Planet. It scored a 9.2 at IGN AU, 9.5 at IGN US, and a 9.7 at IGN UK.
The PS3 has the highest rated Puzzle game between the two consoles. The PS3 version of Puzzle Quest: Challenge of the Warlords receives a 9.3 from IGN while the 360 version only receives a 9.0.
The PS3 has the highest rated JRPG on the two consoles. Eternal Sonata on the PS3 receives an 8.7 from IGN while the 360 version of Eternal Sonata receives an 8.5
The PS3 has the highest rated racing game between the two consoles with Wipeout HD which receives a 9.2 from IGN UK. The 360's highest rated racing game Project Gotham 4 receives a 9.1 from IGN UK but only an 8.1 from IGN US.
The PS3 has by far the highest rated sports action games between the two consoles. Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds and NBA Street Homecourt, an 8.9 and 8.8 respectively, both score much higher than the 360's highest rated game in this category The Bigs which only scored an 8.3.
I am going to give the nod to the PS3 in the strategy genre. The highest rated strategy game on both consoles is Sid Meier's Civilization Revolution which scored an 8.8 on both the PS3 and 360. The second place strategy games on the PS3 and 360 share the same score as well. Pixeljunk Monsters on PS3 and Battlestations Midway on 360 both have scores of 8.5; however, since Pixeljunk Monsters is a PSN game while Battlestations: Midway was a full-priced game at launch, I'm going to have to go with PixelJunk's price being the deciding factor here.
Just as it takes the strategy genre, the PS3 also takes the strategy rpg genre with Valkyria Chronicle. A game that Play Magazine says is proof that the heart of the Dreamcast era still beats in Sega's Japanese Headquarters. IGN AU gave Valkyria Chronicles a 9.1 and IGN US gave it a 9.0. It is by far the best Japanese Strategy Roleplaying game and Japanese Roleplaying game for that matter to be released so far in the US on either the Wii, 360, or PS3 where it makes its home.
The PS3 has by far the best game in the Trivia genre with Buzz! Quiz TV which IGN gives an 8.9. The highest rated game on the 360 in the Trivia genre is Scene It? Lights, Camera, Action which IGN AU gives an 8.0 and IGN US gives a 7.0.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
I skipped over the Card, Casino, Educational Puzzle, Fighting Adventure, Flight, Hunting, Music Action, Pinball, Puzzle Compilation, Puzzle Word Games, Racing Action, Simulation, Sports Simulation, genres because no game rated higher than an 8.0 on either console in those genres.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
So as one can see, the 360 and PS3 tie for the best games in 3 genres. However, in one of those genres, Action, the PS3 has two games that receive the highest possible score from IGN the most respected gaming site on the internet and the 360 only has one.
The 360 has the top game in 10 genres. However, in a number of those genres, they win simply because the PS3 hasn't released a game yet in those genres and the 360 wins in a number of these genres with sub 8.5 games.
The PS3 had the best game in this console generation in 12 genres. And in the genres that they won, with only a few minor exceptions, they had truely dominating games in those categories and they were most often games that had 9+ scores. The PS3 dominated the platforming, Adventure, Japanese RPG, and strategy RPG categories.
13 categories listed above just didn't have any games in them that were worthy of mentioning.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
"In graphics terms. There is no difference. 360 went ahead with Gears, PS3 came back with GT5P and Uncharted. Then lately 360 will be ahead for at least 2 years unless the PS3 has some game we dont know about in the making, this is thanks to Gears 2 and Alan Wake."
There is no way that the 360 will be ahead for two years. It is going to be very lucky if it can be ahead for 3 months. Games like Heavy Rain, Killzone 2, possibly Resistance 2, White Knight Chronicles just for starters are going to have much better graphics than anything we ever see on the 360. And a games like Folklore, Metal Gear Solid 4, and Heavenly Sword in its cinematic portions already do.
Hackers exclusives = NG and NG2, Ninety Nine nights >> Heavenly Sword and DW.
Heavenly Sword and Ninja Gaiden Sigma are far superior to games in this genre on the 360. Play magazine direct descendant of Diehard Gamefan gave Heavenly Sword its Game of the Year Award of 2007, and Sigma even though it had been done before is still superior to the 360 disappointment Ninja Gaiden II.
Racers exclusives = Depends. Realism Forza 2 >> GT5P. For graphics GT5P >> F2. But then you have PGR3 and 4 >>>>>Motorstorm 1&2
Racers are better on the PS3. As shown above the PS3 has the highest rated game in the racing genre in Wipeout HD. Forza 2 in its completed form is only .4 points better than an early demo version of Gran Turismo 5, and as far as comparing Motorstorm to PGR 3 and 4 goes, Motorstorm I received an 8.9 from IGN US while PGR received an 8.8 and Motorstorm II received an 8.3 while PGR 4 received only an 8.1. You have your greater than symbols going in the wrong direction if you know anything about basic math.
"Fighters = VF5 0nline, Dead or Alive 4 >>>> PS3 no exclusives"
Oh well. But considering the fact that the Dead or Alive series is Dead, it can be removed from this genre. As far as the PS3 having no exclusives, the fighting genre really isn't popular enough anymore for that to make much of a difference. And if an upcoming fighter like Tekken 6 sells better on the 360 in the US, sales for the PS3 version in Japan and Others will more than cancel out any advantage that could give the 360.
"RPG's = LO,BD,ToV,TLR,IU,Fable2 >>>>> D3,WKC,VC"
Again you have your signs going in the wrong direction here. Disgaea 3, White Knight Chronicles, and Valkyria Chronicle trump anything in the Japanese rpg genre on the 360. And why did you add Fable II to this list anyway? It's not a JRPG. I guess you were trying to give the 360 games more credibility by doing so. Funny thing though, even with Fable II on your list VC still knocks it out of the park as IGN USA gave Fable II an 88 and Valkyria Chronicles a 90. By far the best jrpg here though is the unreleased White Knight Chronicles. One of Microsoft's biggest failures which is going to cost them heavy is the fact they couldn't get their inferior version of FF XIII on the 360 in Japan.
"Sports = even"
"Stealth = MGS4 >>> Splinter Cell Conviction"
"3rd Person = Gears Of War 1&2 >>>>> Uncharted"
I might give the nod to Gears in the graphics department a little bit more than I used to here, but other than slightly better graphics, Gears really has nothing at all that would allow one to compare it to Uncharted. Uncharted has better characters, a far better story, and much deeper gameplay mechanics which combined make Uncharted a far superior game. Again your arrows are pointing in the wrong direction.
"Music = Lips >>>>>> Singstar"
Yeah, that's like saying Zune >>>>Ipod. In one word nonsensical.
"Platform = Ratchet >>>>>> nothing rated for Banjo yet."
Platform = Little Big Planet, Ratchet, plus the ability to bring back Sly Cooper or Jak and Daxter at any time >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
anything on the 360 in this genre
Wierd games = Dead Rising, BK >>>>>> Anything wierd on PS3????
PixelJunk Monsters, Echocrome,Flower, Flow, The Last Man, Calling All Cars, The Eye of Judgement, Team ICO Project once again reverse the arrows.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________
"Plus I dont believe Blu Ray will ever fully take off. IT will fall somewhere between LD and DVD."
See my earlier note on blu-ray.
My most anticipated games: Whatever Hideo Kojima is going to do next, Final Fantasy XIII, Final Fantasy Versus XIII, Gran Turismo 5, Alan Wake, Wii Sports Resort. Cave Story Wiiware.
