You are right, it's been over a year since that argument died.
The existing argument is simply that the PS3 doesn't have as good a library of great games as other consoles, not that it's library of good games is non-existent.
I too agree that there is a problem with the Wii's 2008 holiday line-up though, and thats coming from a guy that owns the console.
starcraft - Playing Games = FUN, Talking about Games = SERIOUS