| Jordahn said: Yes, you are cherry picking. Remember you said... "It also win both Bonus Rounds - The Orange Box and GTA IV." ...in regards to GTA IV 360 being better than GTA IV PS3. And now you are just making excuses because you cannot refute that other sites and sources have said that the PS3 version of GTA IV is graphically superior while the aveage rating is higher. My successful exposure of your cherry picking is very obvious. This invalidates your credibility. Oh, and in regards to comparison...
"On Sony’s side you will get the more slightly more solid game experience from having a good chunk of data loaded onto the systems hard drive. After the install the PS3 has less lighting glitches and less object pop-ups. The PS3 seems to perform a little better than the Xbox 360 which can be an important to rightfully picky." http://www.extremegamer.ca/multi/reviews/gtaiv.php
"For those who have to decide between the Xbox 360 and PS3 versions, we should mention that these flaws are slightly less noticeable in the PS3 game." http://ps3.gamespy.com/playstation-3/grand-theft-auto-iv/869750p3.html
But remember it really doesn't matter beacuse my original point was that most PS3/360 multiplatform games are so close to graphical quality that it really isn't anything to worry about. "Don't make it an issue because it's not. Unless it's some covert way of bashing the competition by cherry picking what favors your console preference..." And I've proven both points. You specificly pick the sources that favor the 360, and when someone exposes your blatant biasness, you make excuses. EDIT: And here is a source that takes a neutral but reasonable stance... "The Xbox 360 version seems to have a deeper color palette and a little less motion blur/bloom, but the Playstation 3 version seems to have less pop-in and sharper anti-aliasing. Both versions have a few framerate hits here and there, but it never seems to drop the game into unplayable territory." http://www.gamingtrend.com/Reviews/review/review.php?ReviewID=1034 |
Personally it doesn't matter if the game has differences which don't effect the user experience.
Resolution, texture detail, texture filtering don't change the user experience that much.
Anti aliasing does to some extent, but those truely anal about it don't play on consoles. If you love AA how could you turn down 8xMSAA on a Radeon 4870 1gb or 16xCFAA with two of them?
So really it boils down to framerates, pop in (textures and whole buildings), and glitches. Luckily point A wasn't a problem in the first place and B/C can be solved by an install with the NXE.
In any case Fallout 3 is probably best played on the PC and best kept on a PC if you're a true fan of the series and want to play it multiple times.
Tease.
