c0rd on 18 October 2008
It's fine for non-musicians to review Wii Music. Nintendo didn't intend to cater only to them, and if non-musicians end up hating it, they failed in what they set out to do.
The IGN review, however, isn't just a non-musician issue. The guy obviously hates what Wii Music stands for, and compares it to things he "prefers" (GH/RB), even though they're completely different games. He's allowed to give whatever rating he feels Wii Music deserves, but the way he went about it was still childish - I mean, making a video designed to make the game look as bad as possible? His expressed desire to give the game a bad review before it came out didn't exactly help.
