Wow, reading through this thread is torture. I may as well throw mine into the pot then:
GTA 4: I loved the 2D versions, then 3D was... eh. I enjoyed them for a while (~30hours, mainly SA), but I've never finished any. For now I'm done with the series, though the DS game finally looks like something different.
Bioware RPG's (Kotor, Baldur's Gate): I just can't do it. Western RPG's... a taste I have yet to acquire. Hopefully that'll change after I pick up the 360 (haven't given Fable a go yet).
Resistance: If there's one game I played recently that I really don't get, it's this. I cannot see what people like about this game - it feels like Quake I with new weapons and graphics. I played it all the way through anyway due to the co-op, and felt I had to get my money's worth... ugh.
Now, there are plenty of games I'd throw in the overrated pile, but I won't bother going there.
@d21lewis: Haha, sounds like you played the game a bit too much for something you think is shiite. I think I know where you're coming from though - me and a friend always joke about the torture we put ourselves through playing Everquest.
@Khuutra: Just take it as "well received games that you didn't like." That's what he meant, anyway.
