Silent Hill (1-3) - Unmatched Creepiness, and damn near helpless protagonists
Resident Evil 1(PS1)/ Resident Evil (GC): This game set the standard, and had legit scares. Zombie dogs + window = biggest "Oh Shit!" moment ever
Condemned (360): Just getting around to playing this, but the scares are great! There's always a feeling something is off screen, and ready to pounce. I bought part 2, but I haven't tried it yet
Yo Mama!: She's pretty scary but I love playing with her








