So who won the debate?

[Kasz216]

theprof00 said:
The 5000$ tax credit is ridiculous.
Because
1)takes money away from the government, which is desperately needed.
2) Here's 5000, now you are on your own.
3) For someone like me, who is employed 20 hours a week, i might see 400 dollars of that 5000$
4)This plan once again stands to benefit people that make more money
5) Tax credits are NOT the answer!!!!

1) Different from Obama's plans how?

2) That's better then "Your forced to buy healthcare, now you're on your own."  Aside from that his other part of the plan is... you guessed it Healthcare tax credits. 

Also along with that he suggests that the state governments adopt non-profit healthcare plans that cover everyone in there states.  Making it much more efficent and tailored to the specific states then a giant unwieldy national plan. 

He also has many initatives set up to make healthcare costs go down.

3)  Why would you assume the healthcare tax credit gets higher the more money you make? That seems... stupid.

4) How?

5) Why?