By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
appolose said:

I'm saying that by implication, an infinite past is an infinite past endured (which is impossible).

If there was a starting point, then there would not be an infinite past. y=x ; x>0 or y=x^(1/2)

If there was no starting point, then there would be an infinite past. y=x ; x=all real numbers

To beat it all we (as far as we know) cant look past the Big Bang, so we can only assume anyway what happened before or if there was a before anyway.