So 1up/egm are not anti PS3 in their reviews ?

[Bodhesatva]

ckmlb said:
If the only debate is whether Sony is making more money than they should on this title, then both Nintendo and MS have done the same in the past and it wasn't brought up as a major issue.

Does anyone think that Mario Galaxy and Big Brain Academy on the Wii both being priced as full price 50 dollar games makes sense?

Obviously Nintendo has overpriced Big Brain if you start arguing about if what's in the game is worth the price.

The issue is dropping the score of a game that is supposed to be based on the quality of the game because of its price.

This shouldn't be done.

Big Brain absolutely was docked because of its price.

Games should have their reviews docked for price reasons. Reviewing SuperStarDust, as an example, under the same precepts as Metal Gear Solid 4 would be totally unfair. You must take price in to account. If price wasn't taken in to account, every downloadable game and every handheld game would never, ever be capable of getting high scores. 

That's my opinion, you're welcome to yours.