id: Rage Not Cut Because of Xbox 360 Limits

[Jordahn]

NiKKoM said:

Jordahn said:

 

No!!!  We are talking about limitations of the 360 affecting other versions of the game.  You can cherry pick all you'd like to see just the rosey side of things, but I see things from the "big picture" point of view. When I point out specifics, it's in correct context.

 

Yes.. the 360 effected the others in gameplay... but for the better of it.: "Not loading levels while you drive around is a much better decision regardless of platform." the limitation made them to think better about their game & it turned into a positive.. but many are spinning that into a negative..

Graphicwise the 360 version is gimped but that hasn't effected the others.. like iD says.. the 360 version will look worse..

So the first is relevant..  the second isn't..

 

Again you are cherry picking.  Hardly any game developer is going to say that the gameplay to their games is bad especially before its release.  Less load time is better than more in itself, but who's to say the better gameplay doesn't makes up for longer load times???  We don't know how well this game will play, and we will never know how it would have been.  You're cherry picking by taking this positive PR as gospel.  And who's to say that this proven 360 limitation will not negatively affect other games in other ways for other platforms.  Last I recall, the graphics in Doom 3 (an id game) enhanced the gameplay.  But just like Redcoat said:

"Who knows how many times it's already happened but we just haven't heard about it."

...and then some.