Your MP3 picks look a little right to me, but I'm thinking you're lowballing the other to me.
If Super Mario Galaxy is as fun as they say it is, it's not going to get below a 9 from many people at all. Everybody that has played it has come out saying how beautiful the music it, how great it works, and most importantly, it's comparable to the sheer awesomeness of Super Mario 64. I actually don't think I've really read anything negative about this game yet from any of the impressions.
With SSBB, we already know that SSBM has an average of 90 so I'm expecting SSBB to be about the same. It's taking everything fun about Melee and it's then adding some. If it does have online I also wouldn't expect anything less than a 9 for this game.








