I love Resident Evil 4 but part 1 was scarier for me. The first crimson zombie that "woke up" up in the remake on Cube freaked me out! I think the 2d gameplay and shifting camera made you feel less in control which upped the tension factor.
Wii - 3810 4459 0841 8442 - (Message me to add me)
360 - LuminalACE
PS3 - AUS-ACE