ph4nt on 08 September 2008
SMG won more awards ( and GOTY's) than COD4, Bioshock, and The Orange Box.
1998 was Ocarina of Time buy a landslide (It is the highest rated game of all time afterall).
1996 ( I think) was Mario 64.
2002 was Metroid Prime
2001 was Halo ( I think)