@Bodhesatva,
I never said there was a conspiracy, just that I think there were Nintendo games ruled out for superficial reasons and that I think these guys are out of touch with what the market wants.
@endimion
I never said they were the same thing. Which is why I prefaced it by saying that I would of understood a marginal showing. But realize that at some point there is going to be overlap because otherwise one of the two groups is out of touch with reality and since the consumers dictate this market...well you see where I am going.
@ckmlb,
I'm not freaking out, and I honestly do not think this is going to have much of an impact for most people. I may of used strong language in my post to express how I feel about the list but that doesn't necessarily mean I am freaking out about it. I see that a lot of people disagreed with what I said apparently so rather than hash out an opinionated debate I am just going to let it go. After all no point in getting into it if I don't think it will have a large impact, eh?
@KruzeS,
What was on the list in the past doesn't change how I feel about this list (for me at least). I think most people may not of understood what I meant by the superficial comment. I was not necessarily referring to graphics with that comment, but rather conventions in general. Just to use an example, a game like Wario Ware if you knew nothing about it most people would dismiss it out of hand (and did irc).
@HappySquirrel,
You bring up some good points, the format change to E3 this year could of impacted the reactions to these games. I doubt there is any way to quantify it or say that the favor would of gone one way or the other but it does call into question the validity of a comparison between last years awards to these awards. As I said above I don't feel it makes a difference, but this point only solidifies my position in that regard.
@Everyone,
I have had to come back and explain myself a few times now in various threads, and I don't know if it is my wording or people reading into what I say and adding to it in their heads or a little of both. But I promise you that it takes a lot more than this to get me really upset about something, so for those who thought I was steaming over this...sorry but it just wasn't the case. I think for those who take the time to read what I say, you will find that I am not just spouting whatever comes to my head (most of the time lol), but that I have thought it out quite a bit. But nobody is perfect, and I do occasionally misspeak so I try to correct myself and correct others when they get the wrong impression of what I am saying...hopefully that is the case again here.
 |
| To Each Man, Responsibility |
