Fable 2 vs. Gears of War 2- 1st week sales

[starcraft]

erikers said:

starcraft said:

erikers said:
Gears will drop a deuce on Fable 2. Sales and quality wise.

Genre-wise they are completely incomparable, but I don't really expect anything new from Gears 2. I expect both titles to be incredible and AAA, but the quality crown in that case will go to Fable 2 for daring to be fresh.

I like how you know what's going to be fresh when you haven't even played either game. That alone makes me not take you seriously but I'll still respond. The quality crown will go to the game that gets higher ratings and praise. That's all there is to it, not any personal feeling of "freshness" you think one has over the other.

AND I wouldn't be so sure both will be AAA titles...remember Fable ;D

Obviously anything ANY of us say about the title's quality is partially conjecture until the games are out. 

The Gears 2 campaign could end up being six hours long.  Fable 2 might have monumentally shit side-quests and social interaction.

But reasonably based off what has been shown of the two games, its safe to say Fable 2 will bring MORE new stuff to the table, most of which looks awesome. 

But as you say, Fable wasn't AAA, so we'll see what happens.  As I said, I EXPECT them both to be AAA.