Why is only FF and Dragon Quest JPRG:s selling well?

[Riachu]

sc94597 said:

Riachu said:

sc94597 said:

Simulacrum said:

sc94597 said:

Simulacrum said:
...Adventure-action....

I wouldn't consider any Turn Based rpg to have much action. As for Adventuring, how much do you have that in pokemon? I would say Final Fantasy XII is more of an Action-Adventure than Pokemon. Pokemon seems to be much more traditional.

 

 

...WELLLL.....Surely....Argh....WHEN COMPARED TO FINAL FANTASY....Story......No feelings.....all the same...

ITS ADVENTURE-PUZZLE GAME!!!

......

*Runs away*

Since when do RPGs need a good story? Are the first 3 Final Fantasies not rpgs? They all have the same basic find the crystals storyline. Also where did you get the Puzzle from? I don't see too many puzzles in pokemon games. As for Adventure I will say again, is there much adventureing in pokemon games? More so than other rpgs?

 

A RPG doesn't need a good story but there atleast should be more effort in the story department than in the NES era

 

Well in that case all NES rpgs aren't rpgs because they don't have good stories. I'm pretty sure that is wrong though. A RPG that is good most likely does have a decent story, but that doesn't mean a story is a requirement to be an rpg.

 

Diablo is an RPG and the story in that game was shallow. I know that a story isn't a requirement in an RPG