By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Heh! That old review for R&C again. Controversial when released, and still so it appears, because the new, lesser title gets the same score.

Funny.

As I think on it, if I were a GameSpot reviewer, I'd not constrain myself to someone's else's review. I.e.: if R&C: QfB deserves a 7.5 in my opinion, then that is what I'd score it, regardless of what other reviewers may have given R&C:ToD (I'd have given that an 8.5). However, if I was an editor of the reviews, charged to maintain a unified voice for GameSpot, I'd be more concerned. Hell, I'd be tempted to re-review the original game, regardless of the furore it would cause. But, then again, that's why I'm not the editor of GameSpot's reviews.

;)