The Ghost of RubangB on 11 August 2008
I'm not trashing Halo 3. I am explaining why I disagree with Edge's decision. It's a vaguely titled award, and I don't think it meant "best online experience." I'd give that award to Halo 3 on a console, but the PC world blows it away.
But that's Edge's fault for not clarifying the criteria for the award. They said the award goes to the game that "best furthers the creative culture of the gaming world." Whatever that means, I guess in that case I'd go with Portal.
