Oh no, I completely understand. If I was your average John Doe buying games from GameStop, and I found out they did that, it would bother me too. But luckily for me, I'm behind the people swinging the GameStop ugly-stick, so for now I'm safe. Plus, I buy more PS3 games than 360, and while I agree 100% that I'd want a brand new one over a 'borrowed, new' one, a little scratch on a PS3 disc doesn't worry me in terms of playability, huge upside of preferring PS3 Blu-Rays I guess.