Debunking the myth that the PS3 > Xbox360, The real work proves Xbox > PS3

[Mendicate Bias]

ChronotriggerJM said:

Mendicate Bias said:

ChronotriggerJM said:

Mendicate Bias said:
@ Chronotrigger

You keep saying that Epic's first attempt at a game on the PS3 out performs their 360 game so I'm assuming your talking about UT3. As far as I know UT3 performs the same on both consoles, however the 360 has the added fact that it supports split screen for UT3 without any frame rate drops. Maybe using UT3 as an example of the PS3's power wasn't such a good idea...

Maybe taking what I said out of context wasn't the best idea for you :x I said UT3 was better than gears of war, I never said UT3 8 months down the line, or Gears of war 2 wouldn't be better than what they first put on the 360. I'm comparing first's for both. One of which being on unheard of technology :P

 

So comparing a game that came out almost two years after another one is fair because it's on a different console but comparing that same game to its counterpart on the 360 isn't? I think that is called flawed logic.

 

Flawed logic? Sure if you want to view it that way. From what I'm gathering from this thread, is that the engine works really well with the 360 because it's PC-friendly, which the PS3... isn't. Also from what I'm gathering, is that the 360 GPU is more powerful than the PS3 GPU, also that the CELL doesn't work as well as the Xenon for making games, then YES, they're first game on the PS3 (before which Sony workers had to go over to make sure it even ran at all on the PS3), of a game being created for all platforms (vs. one), ran better than Gears of War. I'll root for flawed logic on this one. The fact that Epic said it ran better was already an early sign :/

Besides, before you go and blow any of that out of preportion, how about we clear one thing up, in my opinion, UT3 is nowhere near what I'd call best graphics on PS3 :P Gears of war however on the 360.... let's just say you'll find many supporters ^_^

 

I don't know what your trying to get at with your UT3 argument, so your saying it does run better on the 360 or that it runs well on the PS3 for a game that uses the unreal engine?

Also please don't bring exclusives into this argument, I'm pretty sure if you gave any competent developer over 5 years and a 100 million dollar budget they could make a game that looks just as good as killzone 2 on the 360. Wether it plays good is another story.