I would call the N64 controller. The Z-trigger just felt natural. Also the first time we had an analog stick. The only buttons that where out of place where the four on the Dpad but I only encountered one game that used those (a wrestling game for crying out loud!), and only that made it somewhat usefull (Jet Force Gemini) so I didn't really mind.
Edit: I have to say that weight also matters. I prefer heavier controllers for some reason. I enjoy the force or something (same reason I wear a pretty heavy watch.) The N64 controller + rumblepack felt awesome in that regard.
The Doctor will see you now
Promoting Lesbianism --> 







