By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Groucho said:

I think a lot of folks make the mistake of placing "technical marvel" above "fun game" and "capable of making lots of money"

The 10 games listed by the OP, in my opinion

Technical Marvel order:
Resistance2 > Gears2 > L4D > Fable 2 > LBP > Afrika > SOCOM > (BK, VC, IU)

Game potential fun order (highly subjective):
LBP > BK > (VC, IU, Fable2) > (SOCOM, Resistance2, Gears2) > L4D, Afrika

Attach-rate order (my take, of course):
LBP > Resistance2 > Gears2 > BK > (VC, IU, Fable2) > Afrika > SOCOM > L4D

Raw income order (based on previous orders, and current console totals):
Gears2 > BK > Resistance2 > LBP > IU > Fable2 > SOCOM > Afrika > VC > L4D


(yeah, I'm calling L4D as a dud)

If the Xbox360 is considered technically inferior then Gears 2 is in itself a technical marvel. *BOLD1*

Valve has made some of the most successful FPS games in the history of gaming. Their sales of HL1/2/3 alone exceed 15million. They have fun down to an art form. It explains their success yaknow? *Bold2*

Attach rate is a factor of sales vs consoles in the wild. How can LBP have a higher attach rate and a lower income than R2?!?!? *Bold3*

Reverse that, If valve sells a game for $50 they make $50... Console developers would be lucky to get $30. So one million sales on steam = 2 million through retailers on a console. They could easily sell 1.5million online and another 1.5 million on the Xbox360 so their gross income would most likely exceed everything else on the list by a fair margin.  *Bold4*

The best lineup? Shooters - Xbox360 takes the cake here, L4D + Gears 2 vs Socom + R2? No contest. Its Valve + Epic two AAA developers vs two AA developers. If KZ2 is included I would give a slight nod to Sony.

JRPGs - IU + TV + LR = no contest.

WRPGs - Fable 2 + Fallout 3 exclusive content vs what exactly? No contest.

Music games = Small advantage with Rockband timed exclusive... Apart from that its even.

Actiony/GTA type games = No idea... I didn't keep track with games like Infamous etc.

 

 

 


 

 



Tease.