By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - HDD vs SSD

This may have been done before but if it hasnt,these are the advanteges of the 2.

What they are

HDD or hard disc drive use spinning discs and a arm to read them,I think most of us know this but just in case you didnt,thats how it works

SSD or solid state drive is basically flash memoy but much larger,I could explain it but it might be better if for the people who want to know just look it up,its kinda hard for me to explain it

Advantages between the the 2

read/write speed   Win SSD

SSD is signifacantly faster than a hdd,even the fastest hdd can be surpassed by a decent SSD.I would post the difference but it all depends on who makes the drive and rpm affects how fast a hdd can be

 

Power consomption (thought I would put this in as well) Win SSD

SSD uses less power than HDDs so this is great for portable devices,its good for portable gaming devices like the psp and ds.This also meens less heat which is another pro for the portable market.

 

Reliability   Win SSD

I have seen a few things about the reliability of ssd and the few problems I have seen are being adressed or have been but overall its in SSDs favor,its estimated that they will last 5+ years while HDDs have had problems sometimes and only last on average 3 to 5 years.Its usually because the arm that reads the discs wears out.

 

How much space they can hold   Win HDD

HDDs hold more than what SSDs can,im not shur if this is true anymore but when the first ipod released it had a 1 gig HDD that held I think about 2000 songs,well my 4gb flash zune holds the same amount,so that would meen every 4 gbs with a SSD would be 1 gb for a HDD,like I said it might not be exactly like that anymore and the gap could be narrowing.

 

Cost   Win HDD

HDDs are more cost affective you could say then SSDs,a 300GB HDD will cost around 100 dollars while the cheapest 120GB SSD will cost around 300 dollars but you may be able to get them cheaper.It ia said that the price of both are falling at the same pace so HDDs will continue to dominate laptops and computers for probably the next 5 years while SSDs will dominate the portable market.

 

For gaming im not shur but I think for the next gen a SSD and HDD combo would be great,by then SSDs would be cheaper so I was thinking why not have a 10 or maximum 60 GB internal SSD and have a 100 GB external HDD or perhaps make it a option with a more expensive bundle.I know the arcade already has a 256 mb internal flash but thats not alot,good enough to save your games though and I know 100 gigs is not alot but if you look at it like this you could save all your games to it and perhaps have enough space to install 1 game so it should load up fast,and the 100 gig HDD could be used for every thing else.Most likely though by next gen 250 might be the smallest for a HDD and a 500 or perhaps more could be the max.

Well thats it,just thought I would point out the difference of the 2 in case you did not know and the benefits between the 2.

 

 



Proud suporter of the Xbox family

 

 

 

 

Around the Network

I wanna put a SSD in my PS3...but until 160GB are $1/GB no sale!



Solid state also runs cooler. I was working with a Macbook Air for a day. The thing has no moving parts, not even fans. It stayed relatively cool all day.



Has of right now, I wouldnt really recommend buying a SSD. It costs a lot and that technology changes really fast. Theres a new faster SSD almost each week.

You are better of with two or more HDDs in RAID 0.

And the space is the same. When you said 4gb flash = 1gb on a HDD, its not true, the values doesnt change like that.

If you really want SSD but only got enough for 1, take a HDD too for storage. You put all your games and Windows on the SSD and everything else stays on the HDD, that way everything will load faster.

And to correct you again, you can get 1TB HDD for about 80-90$ CAN.

(I took PC has an example because its not used in consoles yet)



tedsteriscool said:
I wanna put a SSD in my PS3...but until 160GB are $1/GB no sale!

Yea I know they are like 3$ per Gb and HDDs are liked 20-30 cents per GB for a 2.5 inch drive



Proud suporter of the Xbox family

 

 

 

 

Around the Network

you guys who want SSD, my suggestion is to wait until they've solved the stuttering and slowdown problems first.



Proud Sony Rear Admiral

fearfulSPARTAN said:

How much space they can hold   Win HDD

1.HDDs hold more than what SSDs can,im not shur if this is true anymore but when the first ipod released it had a 1 gig HDD that held I think about 2000 songs,well my 4gb flash zune holds the same amount,so that would meen every 4 gbs with a SSD would be 1 gb for a HDD,like I said it might not be exactly like that anymore and the gap could be narrowing.

 

Cost   Win HDD

2.HDDs are more cost affective you could say then SSDs,a 300GB HDD will cost around 100 dollars while the cheapest 120GB SSD will cost around 300 dollars but you may be able to get them cheaper.It ia said that the price of both are falling at the same pace so HDDs will continue to dominate laptops and computers for probably the next 5 years while SSDs will dominate the portable market.

 

 

1. What are you talking about?  Makes no sense...

 

2. I just got a 1.5 terabyte Seagate harddrive for my new build, and it was 88 dollars



Here's a video from my band's last show Check out more (bigger) videos here http://www.youtube.com/user/icemanout
Spankey said:
you guys who want SSD, my suggestion is to wait until they've solved the stuttering and slowdown problems first.

They did year ago with release of Indilix/Intel/Samsung controllers.

 

Now i have one for my OS drive, will soon get one more for netbook  and once they are 1$ per GB i'll get one for my PS3.



PROUD MEMBER OF THE PSP RPG FAN CLUB

SSD basically does everything better than HDD except it costs a lot more.

Currently I would say the minor to medium sized advantages you get from SSD are not worth the price multiplier for the amount of space you want, but maybe 3-5 years down the line I would think the price difference should be better.