9.5/10 everything i wanted love last guardian :)

8/10, could have been a 9/10, if not for the leaks. The shown Uncharted 2 gameplay was the highlight of E3 for me. Can't wait. 8-)

7+, better than M$, but not by that much,
M$ made good first impression,

Sony was half about PSP and half about PS3, while M$ was whole time only about x360.

Overall, the Last Guardian + FFXIV = EPIC WIN.
And, if i haven`t seen the eraly footage of Trico Project, it would be 10+ of 10. =)

Also, they definitely should have shown atleast teaser of Agent.

Sony > M$ >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Nintendo. :)

Peace Walker/10

sony gets a 8/10 ms gets a 7.5/10

Sony: 8.1/10

I'll just copy paste the relevant parts from this post.

Sony: Mag is totally amazing, will have to see if they can make it accessible but yeah its a definative moment for FPS online on consoles. Uncharted 2 was also fantastic. I was ready to give it to them right there. Final Fantasy XIV, hmm will have to wait n see im not too impressed because MMO = PC for me until proved otherwise. ICO game was pretty arty, not my scene but its an amazing thing anyway and have to give it respect. I liked their Wiitoo type device, but the demonstration felt really hashed together at the last minute. It makes me think that the 2010 release date for spring would be a soft launch if at all. Gran Turismo truely is a mega hit, its pretty big but seeing it likely slip from 2009 is as much a disapointment for me as it is an awesome experience seeing the WRC and Nascar type gameplay modes. Lastly that car racing game was pretty off the hook too. God of War was really cool too, but the unexpected hit for me was that car game! Man... Awesome stuff.

On the face of it I will probably give it to Sony marginally. Many of the 360 games aren't different enough, better enough from an equivelent multi-plat. MAG is something im wary of but the concept is totally fantastic and its definately one of the show winners for me and the Kart racing game was so slick and came out of nowhere. Joyride has nothing on it. Microsoft has more great titles but Sony has more special titles. For example Forza 3 is matched by not GT5 but NFS: Shift. In all I would give Sony about an 8.1/10 and Microsoft a 7.4/10.

Apperently not. Either that, or GoW 3, Uncharted 2, MAG, and everything else are not games at all.

Sony haters are having a rave.

7/10

Pros

• Uncharted 2 footage -- amazing
• PSP Go -- even if it was already leaked, they did a great job at covering it
• Create and Share Kart Game -- looked like they took the ideas from LBP and Maio Kart and made something pretty cool.  Definately on my radar
• Metal Gear Stuff -- I don't care too much about this but they showed off a good chunk of this while showing the PSP Go
• FFIV -- Good for them, hope they stay true to FFXI

Cons

• Boring beginning with numbers.
• Project Trico trailer -- Great trailer, but we've seen it before
• Home commercial -- saw it last month
• Clip montages -- borign clips of games already out or clips we've seen before with the added bonus of not telling us what games they're showing off.  Woohoo!
• Motion controller -- poorly showed off tech demo, plus it's releasing next year with no current games to show or final controller and the Wii is releasing the same thing this month (or is next month?)
• The Agent -- Give me more than a name
• MAG -- just wasn't that interesting.  It was mainly of a guy standing there giving orders.  I get what they were trying to do but wasn't that interesting to watch.
• Didn't show much new
• Assassin's Creed II -- To go with the above point, I want to see new gameplay of new games.
• FFXIII -- Nothing really new here, just a lot of CG with some in game stuff at the end.

Don't think I'm missing anything.

there was heavy rain though :p in their game montage. Twice !

And tekken 6 !

Regardless.. I give it a 10 out of 10. Yes it was pure fucking awesome ! that's right Kaboom baby !

6. FF XIV looked good but that was about it for me. also the PSP go's price is outrageous!