Wii no doubt about it

*First Post*

Mario is obviously gonna rule. But you guys are silly if you think either nights or dewy are actually going to be good games. Nights=developed by Sonic Team=given recent developer track record going to be pretty but buggy and fundamentally flawed. Mark my words Nights will get 6.5s-7.0s when its reviewed.

I wouldn't put much stock in Dewy either. May be decent, but I have a feeling its going to be a disappointment for those trying to hype it up. I'd probably go with Zack and Wiki being the sleeper hit, not Dewy.

Line-up wise, Wii wins on Mario alone.

I would have included Uncharted in the PS3's platformer group, but that's just me.
Otherewise of the titles you listed, the ones I'll be getting are Mario and Ratchet.

Mario
Nights
Crash

I mean cmon. All 3? Not even close. Even if all WIi had was Galaxy it would still win by default.

Has anyone even heard of anything bad about Dewey's Adventure other than it's too cute?  I don't think it's going to be a huge seller this holiday season but I think it's going to be up there in the same catagory of awesome as Okami.

what category are you putting uncharted in, i guess action/adventure? i would include it in both A/A and platformer, and call a Wii/PS3 tie... whatever... SMG is the only thing i'll be missing.

Speaking of Okami, the Wii is getting a port of it.

Also, Ratchet is a damn fun game and a damn fun series, and it looks awesome on PS3, so even though I still have to give it to Wii for SMG, Ratchet in my mind is the only other game on the entire list I REALLY want. Nights would be cool maybe, but not until after SMG and Ratchet. Also, though, Ratchet DOES have better graphics than Mario Galaxy. Might not count for too much, but hey, it's something. Also Mario cannot make things disco dance or ...uh....turn into sheep. Yeah. At least he has fire flowers and stars this time.

munkeh is just jealous he isnt going to be able to play mario galaxy, duh

i mean come on, SMG..need i say more..

imo, mario needs it's own category because it is in an entire different league in comparison to the other games.

they cannot even be named in the same sentence imo.

you shall see...

Hey, I may be getting Mario Galaxy first, but who says I'll like it more or play it more? Maybe Insomniac kicked major ass with TOD....I'm totally getting them both.

I definitely liked all of the ratchet games better than mario sunshine... 

im a sonyfanboy as u can see from my other posts but im not gonna be so blinded to say the ps3 has a better platfroming line up then the wii. I love every rachet and clank game and think its gonna be a great game but wii just with smg beats them all