Both excellent games with great production values. However ROTTR excells in creating better puzzles (something I find weak in Uncharted games)and has more to do in the shape of side quests and collectables. It has also kept my attention right through, whereas I found Uncharted 4 to become a bit of a chore toward the latter staged of the game. I really hope we get more modern Tomb Raider, just please no silly timed exclusive stuff this time.

I haven't played RotR (yet) but I wouldn't be surprised if I end up liking it more than U4 too.

Yes, both excellent games with great production values. However I would argue about ROTTR's excellence in creating puzzles. I personally think both game do a very mediocre job at it. Personally I like U4's story and characters much more than ROTTR. But again, both excellent games.

I made the same thread with the same opinion like 5 months ago. All i got to say is good luck, you're a brave one. But hey, I am alive.

Both are great, but I think Uncharted 4 has overall more memorable moments due to better plot and more likeable characters, also faster action sequences.

I enjoyed Uncharted 4 more.

fite me irl 1v1

As someone who prefer games with an open world i also prefer ROTR so much that i bought it on PC and PS4 and if by some miracle they release both games on Switch i'll buy them again. Uncharted 4 was a great game though

I plan on buying both next month for my PS4.

The positive is that we have 2 amazing games where this is a discussion. I'm glad if one isn't clearly better than the other, just means 2 fantastic games for me to play rather than 1.

10/10

so do i and i haven't bought either of them yet,always tomb raider for me