I thought it was this year the Best Lineup in Xbox History but i was wrong.

It is Next Years Lineup THE Best Lineup in The History of Xbox.

http://www.gamespot.com/articles/xbox-one-has-best-lineup-for-2016-exec-says/1100-6432747/

I don't understand the point of this thread, to me the best year for 7th gen HD consoles was probably 2009 when all the good shit started to show up up until the end of their life cycle, every year has been pretty good since 2009.

I'm just disagreeing with their new PR line.  Started with 2015 is the best ever and now it's 2016 is the best ever.  

I think 2007 was better.  What's the problem with that? 

Well there is a difference between simply disagreeing (which implies there is opinion involved) and accusing them of lieing in your OP and wondering why there is no accountability (which implies this is a factual matter which can be quantifiably measured).

I mean, ok, you disagree. So where did they lie?

They lied because they announced THE BEST lineup in Xbox history before the game were received by the critics. Now that the lineup is already out and the reviews are in the wild, we can factually see that this wasnt THE best lineup ever. It was 2007.

This is a weak argument and assumes that whatever tops Metacritic is factually superior.

Factually, based on peoples opinions LOL.

Some users on this site and die hards seem to soley rely on Metacritic scores alone to tell a good game and back up their opinions, it's pretty depressing.

Yes, people opinions. But what other way do we have to gauge the quality of a game? Let alone the quality of a years lineup?

Yeah, reviews.

So you are saying that the "Best Line-up ever" PR is bullshit?

Not saying anything about that PR speech, I was referring to users relying on Meta as an end all to be all both opinion and fact wise, it's been made super clear the stances people took on that PR article anyway.