Without being privy to the data you really can't make foregone conclusions like this. The article states Forza Horizon which was after Fifa. UK is seeing a lot more deals recently than the US is.

First of all, I don't really need anything to back it up because the OP doesn't have anything to back it up.

But even then:

As I said, that's like selling 300k a week in the US (yes, valid comparison). That would be 1,500,000 (!!!) in September's NPD. Even with Destiny and the PS4 having 2nd biggest HW sales in history, they did 820,000. As I said, 2nd biggest September in history, and it's not even close.

We also have other sources like Sony saying the sold 1m in the UK recently, that the PS4 is outselling Xbox One 1.5:1 in the UK and that on FIFA week Xbox One sales increased by 155% with a drop afterwards. You can easily find articles for all of those.

So again. It's possible during FIFA and Destiny weeks. Not on a consistent basis, that's nuts.

Jeez. Again, I'm not saying it didn't happen a couple of weeks. I'm saying, "are selling 50k a week at the moment" sounds like it's a trend. It can't be. A few weeks here and there yes. Not something that's gonna happen every week from FIFA onwards.

The UK is not a big enough market to sell 50k a week regularly, even in October. That's like selling 300k a week in the US. A couple of weeks yes, probably what they referred to (if the article exists at all because I couldn't find it. Maybe print?). Consistently, no.

Jeez. Again, I'm not saying it didn't happen a couple of weeks. I'm saying, "are selling 50k a week at the moment" sounds like it's a trend. It can't be. A few weeks here and there yes. Not something that's gonna happen every week from FIFA onwards.

The OP is taken from GAF which is taken from MCV. They get HW and SW from GFK! Unless you really want to say that the trakers are wrong, go ahead.

Your second to last paragraph doesn't really say much, besides that after Destiny and Fifa, there was a spike and then a drop (we don't know how much of a drop though).

Without comparing the UK market to the US market, which as of the release of Fifa has been very different in terms of price and deals, you can't say that it's not possible for 50k a week combined. It might be nuts, yes, but if the tracker says so, you can't go against them. If you do, you might as well go after NPD, as they could've then over tracked Septemers numbers.

Where's that article? In any case, I already said it could have been misinterpreted or badly worded.

But whatever. Believe what you will. If you think they're selling over 50k every week with any consistency be my guest. I guess we expect 300k a week combined every week of December too.

But you not give a good reason why not...

This are the facts.

1  PS4 + Xbo = 50K   Possible ratio 30K PS4 20K Xbo (that is a guess yeah)
2 Stated by yourself is that X360 did average 19k
3 September/October/November/December are the best months for sales so it would mean that Xbox 360 did more than 19k in Sept/Oct/Nov/Dec and could easy sell 20-25K weekly in september and so it would be not shocking that Xbo did 20K weekly in September...

Where's that article? In any case, I already said it could have been misinterpreted or badly worded.

But whatever. Believe what you will. If you think they're selling over 50k every week with any consistency be my guest. I guess we expect 300k a week combined every week of December too.