First, how is this unbiased? Well, I have not played either game, so, my observation is completely unbiased.

Win/Tie
----------

Graphics: Sony. Based on screenshots alone.

Price/Value: Nintendo. You can't beat a $0.99 unless Sony decide to give it free like so many other titles.

Gameplay: Tie. I have played neither.

Replayability: Sony. Track builder alone will make you spend more time building tracks than actually karting.

Sound: Tie. Both sound about the same with sound off.

Verdict: Sony won. Sony edges out slightly against Nintendo even thought it cost at least 20x more at discount prices. You are buying quality here.

Here are 2 screenshots to prove that Sony makes superior karting game.

Haha, your threads always make me smile. Much better mock thread than Rol's

I find it amusing how little big planet barley won this :S

"Gameplay: Tie. I have played neither."

I call bullshot on the lbp karting pic! Unfair comparison! I demand re-evaluation!

laaaammmeee... Mole Kart 2 Evolution is out...



SEE!!! it has ABSOLUTELY NEW TUNNELS COME



And ENRICHMENT TRANSFORMATIONS, ENDLESS EVOLUTION....

Yes I miss carmina2000 a lot.. Mole kart 2 reminds me of her...

Nintendo Mole Kart has the "Nintendo Factor" (though it's not made by Nintendo). With that added to the equation, MK certainly wins.

I second this!

Yo, you forgot "rip-off factor". Which game rips off most effectively? Which game most blatantly copies, while still retaining a sense of individuality?

Your totally right....LBP is totally ripping off Modnation racers. Nice call :P