Uhm, I don't think anybody said this but you should play Eternal Darkness it got high ratings a 9.6 on IGN and a 9.5 or was it 9.8 on GameSpot. You can still look -up the old reviews... matter of fact here's how confident I am that you should play this game :
http://cube.ign.com/objects/015/015887.html#reviews
That is the link. Trust me!
Also Fire Emblem is very fun. It is my favorite RPG. It took me a Chapter to get used to the main story telling vehicle (text and pictures) after the awesome cut scene but once you get into the meat of the conflict you soon don't care any more. Also turn off the battle animations.